August 11, 2009

Fibonnaci Analysis - Why It Can Sometimes Be Completely Useless

I personally believe that every forex trader should at least have a basic understanding of fibonacci analysis and the key levels to watch out for, which in my view are the 50% and the 61.8% levels. By plotting these two levels you can form an idea of what kind of price targets you should aim for whenever you trade any price reversals.

For example if the price has moved 1000 pips (from the low point to the high point) and is reversing back downwards quite strongly then a 50% retracement, ie 500 points, would be a good place to exit your position.

However some traders like to wait for these retracement levels to be hit before entering a new position in the direction of the initial trend. Now this is where fibonacci analysis can be a little bit hit and miss.

While you will find plenty of instances where the price has bounced nicely off of the 50% or 61.8% retracement levels and resumed it's trend, unfortunately there are just as many instances where the price has ignored these levels and just gone straight through them.

To demonstrate this point you only have to look at the recent movement of the GBP/USD pair. As you can see from the chart below the pair moved from a low point of 1.6339 all the way up to 1.7044.

It then reversed back downwards but although both the 50% and 61.8% retracement levels were both taken out (and therefore would have been good exit points), the price failed to bounce back upwards from either of these levels, so those traders who were banking on a continuation trend from either of these levels will have been left disappointed because the price didn't respond to them at all.

So the point I want to make is that although fibonacci levels are good for determining possible exit points, they are often nowhere near as reliable when you are looking for entry points for continuation trends.

GBP_USD11-09.png

 

 

Filed under by

del.icio.us Digg Furl Reddit Ask blogmarks Google Netscape Socializer StumbleUpon Technorati Windows Live Yahoo! Help

Permalink • Print • Comment

5 Comments on Fibonnaci Analysis - Why It Can Sometimes Be Completely Useless »

August 12, 2009

Daniel Shilina @ 4:56 am:

Fibonacci ratios are indeed very important in Forex trading. I think the 38.2% level is very important also. Fibonacci is good for using the ratios as extensions also. It's amazing. Thanks.

Valtrg @ 3:07 pm:

Fibonnaci Analysis - Completely Useless!!!
I don`t agree with upper title.

Same analysis on GBPUSD - Day chart:
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2577/3815032716_057b79a5e4_o.png

Support exact @ 61.8%…

James Woolley @ 9:51 pm:

Hi Valtrg,

Yes you're right if you go back far enough, then yes this was a nice bounce off the 61.8% level.

But that's my point. Sometimes the markets respond to these key fibonacci levels and we see a perfect bounce, but on other occasions the price ignores them completely.

This is why I don't believe anyone can make consistent profits just using fibonacci analysis alone because it's too unreliable.

August 13, 2009

Valtrg @ 10:24 am:

Hi,

My rules for trading fibonacci levels!
Never trade only levels but look for other confirmations.

Current example on GBPUSD:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3493/3816711997_a96a1220ba_o.png

Wee have confluence with Daily fibo 61.8% / H4 and H1 support and on H1 - RSI(14) Bullish divergence.

Valtrg

Free Webinar about trading with RSI:
http://www.harmonictrader.com/32109webinarrsibamm.htm

TradeProfits @ 1:51 pm:

It is always possible to find some tool to confirm an idea of the upcomming move. I think a lot of people usses fib for that. Don't make up your mind of a direction or move before you look at the chart, do a combination of technical and fundamental analysis, and then look to enter a trade. Don't decide and then find something to confirm that decision..